Business lobbyists and conservative think tanks are not big fans of President Bidenâs proposed tax increases on the wealthy.
The Tax Foundation has said that Biden wants to raise the capital gains tax to âhighs not seen since the 1920s.â Suzanne Clark of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce called the same plan âoutrageous.â Jay Timmons of the National Association of Manufacturers called the proposed increase in the corporate tax rate âarchaic.â And Brendan Bechtel, the chief executive of the construction company that bears his family name, said that âit doesnât feel fair.â
All of this rhetoric has obscured a basic fact about Bidenâs tax plan: It would not actually raise tax rates on the rich to high levels, historically speaking.
If all of Bidenâs proposed tax increases passed â on the corporate tax, as well as on investment taxes and income taxes for top earners â the total federal tax rate on the wealthy would remain significantly lower than it was in the 1940s, â50s and â60s. It would also remain somewhat lower than during the mid-1990s, based on an analysis that Gabriel Zucman of the University of California, Berkeley, did for The Morning.
This chart shows the total federal rate for both the top 0.01 percent of earners (who currently make about $28 million a year on average) and the top 1 percent of earners (who make $1.4 million on average):
Tax hikes and economic booms
The data is a reminder of just how far taxes on the wealthy have fallen over the past 70 years. In the decades just after World War II, many corporations paid about half of their profits in federal taxes. (Shareholders, who are disproportionately affluent, effectively pay those taxes). Today, corporate taxes are only about one-fourth as large, as a share of G.D.P., as they were in the 1950s and â60s.
The declines are not all ancient history, either. For most of the past quarter-century, taxes on the affluent have continued falling, including the rates on corporate profits, personal income, stock dividends, stock holdings and inheritances. Barack Obama reversed some of the declines, but only some. âThe net effect over the past 25 years of federal income tax policy has been to reduce the overall revenue collected from top earners,â Owen Zidar, a Princeton University economist, told me.
Whether you like Bidenâs plan or dislike it, it is not radical. For that reason, it is highly unlikely to have the harmful effects on economic growth that its critics are claiming. Remember: In the 1990s, the last time tax rates were as high as the ones Biden has proposed, the economy boomed. It also grew rapidly after World War II, when tax rates were higher yet.
History suggests that tax rates on the wealthy are not the main determinant of economic growth (and, if anything, higher taxes on the rich can sometimes lift growth). The main effect of Bidenâs tax plan probably wonât be on the level of G.D.P. It will instead be on the relative tax burden that wealthy people pay. When they criticize the plan as unfair, archaic and outrageous, they are really saying that they enjoy paying low tax rates.
Biden said that the U.S. would admit up to 62,500 refugees in the next six months, reversing his decision to keep a lower limit set by Donald Trump.
The E.P.A. plans to limit a class of climate-warming chemicals used in air-conditioning and refrigeration.
Richard Cordray, an ally of Senator Elizabeth Warren, will oversee federal student aid, putting him at the center of Democratic disagreements over forgiving debt.
Representative Liz Cheney, the No. 3 House Republican, accused Trump of âpoisoning our democratic systemâ by making false claims of voter fraud.
The countryâs increasing diversity isnât doing as much to help Democrats as liberals hope, Nate Cohn explains.
Business and Media
Bill and Melinda Gates are divorcing, raising questions about the future of their philanthropic foundation.
Verizon will sell Yahoo and AOL to the private equity firm Apollo for $5 billion, about half the amount it paid to buy the companies.
Pandemic disruptions have led to shortages of â and price increases for â lumber, cleaning products, microchips and other commodities.
The Los Angeles Times announced its next top editor: Kevin Merida, previously of ESPN and The Washington Post.
Other Big Stories
At least 23 people, including children, died in Mexico City after a subway overpass collapsed.
Daniel Libeskind, an architect known for the Jewish Museum in Berlin and the new World Trade Center site, will lead the renovation of the Tree of Life synagogue in Pittsburgh, site of a 2018 mass shooting.
Severe weather is threatening the South, with tornadoes in four states.
Jordi Cuixart is serving nine years in a Spanish prison. His crime: supporting a referendum for Catalan independence.
When the World Trade Organization meets this week, should it waive Covid vaccine patents to increase access for poorer countries?
No: Vaccines are hard to make, so waivers alone wonât lift supply, the Center for Global Developmentâs Rachel Silverman and others argue. And companies have shown they will work voluntarily to increase doses, Andrei Iancu writes in Stat.
âFear and joyâ: Stunning photos from Stromboli.
A Times classic: Can you guess whether these neighborhoods voted for Biden or for Trump?
Lives Lived: He was born Joseph Jacques Ahearn, but his mother thought Jacques dâAmboise would be better suited to the ballet world. After he became a dancer, dâAmboise found stardom in New York and Hollywood. He died at 86.
ARTS AND IDEAS
The incredible making of âAll the Girlsâ
By the time last year that producers were ready to record a new album by the soprano Rebecca Luker, she was too sick to sing. A.L.S. had robbed her of her strength.
But the producers did not give up.
They created what Tommy Krasker, the head of Lukerâs label, called âthe first studio album made without ever stepping in the studio.â They used recordings of one of Lukerâs final performances â and the rehearsals for it â while musicians recorded material at home during lockdown. The producers mixed the sounds, âand by some miracle what emerged sounded pristine,â the critic Jesse Green writes in The Times.
The album, âAll the Girls,â also featuring the soprano Sally Wilfert, came out two days after Lukerâs death in December. Green calls it beautiful and funny. (It includes this song, which is worth watching.)
Tonight, Lukerâs colleagues and friends will tell stories and sing songs from her career at a fund-raising concert you can stream. â Claire Moses, Morning writer
PLAY, WATCH, EAT
What to Cook
Originally posted on https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/04/briefing/biden-tax-plan-wealthy.html